High Performance HVAC Reviews Home
HVAC Reviews
Written by Richard   
Wednesday, 24 December 2008 00:46

HVAC Replacement Guide, HVAC Buyers Guide, Air Conditioning and Heating Buyers Guide

HVAC Reviews Criteria & Ratings

How We Rate Products

High Performance HVAC reviews and rates HVAC Products along with other related home products available on the market that consume energy. Energy and how we use it is a big subject these days and High Performance HVAC wants to help you make the right decisions when purchasing HVAC equipment. High Performance HVAC applies our knowledge to rate the equipment and products we review. We give you a technical review cutting through the sales embellishments made by manufacturers to attract you to purchase their product. Of course any review has an opinion but we take a technical approach to reviewing these products and unmask the hype. We give you the pluses and minuses for purchasing these energy consuming products. Sometimes we will be brash when describing something a manufacturer claims because some claims they make is simply silly and uses true hype. We counter the hype giving you a technical but fun review. It is our hope that all manufacturers are accountable when describing their products so the consumer isn't lead astray by the hype. When we find a claim that is so outrageous we will issue a Caution Alert for that particular manufacturer. Currently there is only one manufacturer with a Caution Alert tag.

When we find a product where the manufacturer makes outrageous claims we will issue a Caution Alert tag until they either prove the outrageous claim or issue a press release showing where they erred in their test procedures and that they are reassessing the efficiency rating on the equipment or product. A Caution Alert means you need to ask the representative to explain the claims made in the sales literature from that manufacturer they are representing for that particular product. Basically, a Caution Alert is telling you the claims made do not make logical sense and the test used to determine this claim is flawed or the test was not conducted under normal and fair conditions that you, the consumer, would experience after this product is installed in your residence or business.

Currently all manufacturers of Two-Stage gas and oil furnaces and boilers need to retest all the Two-Stage gas and oil furnaces and boilers in their inventory because the current DOE test for rating efficiency for gas furnaces (AFUE) is a test released by DOE in 1993 for single-stage conventional gas furnaces. As of this writing the National Institute of Standards has recommended to the DOE that they accept this new test procedure for Two-Stage gas and oil furnaces and boilers to make the test credible for Two-Stage gas and oil furnaces and boilers. As we develop the site we will include more information about efficiency ratings because energy consumption has become a very important factor in many peoples' decision to purchase equipment. We simply want to make sure the end consumer is educated about purchasing products and the credibility of the claims made by manufacturers in rating their products. We encourage users of High Performance HVAC reviews to ask sales representatives about this when they make the sales pitch for you to to purchase one of their Two-Stage gas or oil products.

All we ask of you is that you give us a review of the HVAC equipment you own. Please be fair and honest in your review and remember there are many very good HVAC and home products available out there for purchase. It is highly recommended you get a good contractor to install the equipment. An article in a recent trade magazine claimed approximately 50% of HVAC equipment is installed incorrectly leading to problems with the equipment, poor or improper air flow or water flow, and the poor installation results in a reduction in the rated efficiency of the equipment. Installation is important so make sure you hire a professional to install the equipment. A professional contractor will do the job right and save you lots of money in energy costs and add life to the equipment itself. Before you make negative a review you need to answer these basic questions:

  • Was the equipment inspected by a third party agency? In other words was a permit pulled for the new installation so the new installation could be inspected by local authorities for safety and proper installation according to the code applicable to the installation.
  • Did the equipment recieve proper start-up by a qualified technician? After new equipment is installed it should be started-up by a qualified technician for final check-out and tuning before the contractor says the job is complete.
  • If you had a forced air system installed was the ductwork replaced or did it have a major overhaul? Many old outdated duct systems leak and are inefficient. A big problem with old duct is that it may not be the proper size for the new installation. This is very important for the proper operation of the new forced air system and the efficiency of the new equipment.
  • Was a proper load calculation done to determine the true size of the equipment necessary to handle the load? There are many systems out there that are undersized and oversized. Both oversizing and undersizing will decrease the efficiency of the equipment and cause problems with comfort.

In many of the review sites I have been to and read the negative reviews I can almost bet the house that 50% or more of the people who gave the negative review cannot answer the above questions with a positive, confident answer.


HVAC Reviews, High Performance HVAC reviews criteria, air conditioning and heating reviews

Last Updated on Tuesday, 23 February 2010 15:19
 
Maytag or Rheem or
Written by Richard   
Tuesday, 16 February 2010 23:25

Maytag or Rheem or???

To: richard

Subject: highperformancehvac.com: Maytag vs. Rheem gas electric packaged heater AC

From: Steve

This is an enquiry e-mail via http://highperformancehvac.com

Hi, We're trying to compare Maytag and Rheem gas/electric heating/AC packaged units to replace our old one. The Maytag (15 SEER, 4 ton; PPG1GFX048120) has 2-stage heating and cooling and a variable speed blower, and 12 years parts and labor. The Rheem (14SEER, 4 ton; RRPL-B) has single stage and variable speed blower, 10 yr parts and we can purchase a 10 yr labor warranty. The Maytag has seemingly better features, but we're not familiar with Maytag heater/AC units, but know the Rheem name, and have been told its highly rated. One heating and air conditioning company quoted the Maytag at more than $2500 less than two other companies quoted the Rheem. Are you familiar with the Maytag, and do you know if it's as reliable and as highly rated as the Rheem? Also, whether the wholesale price of the Maytag is that much less than the Rheem, or is the price difference more likely to different labor costs and profit margins of the installation companies?

Thanks for any information, Steve

Last Updated on Thursday, 25 February 2010 00:26
 
Goodman GPG15M Packaged Heat Pump
Editor rating
 
4.0 User rating
 
0.0 (0)

This is an enquiry e-mail via http://highperformancehvac.com/air-conditioner-furnace-reviews/

Richard, I was wondering if you could give me your technical review on the following unit I am considering purchasing.

The unit is a Goodman. Model GPH15M Packaged Heat Pump, 15 seer. Also, your opinion on Goodman units in general.

Any help would be appreciated. Thanks, Mike

Mike, Thanks for the email and your request for a technical review of the Goodman Model GPH15M Packaged Heat Pump. A good friend of mine has a relationship with Goodman dealer as an installing contractor and I forwarded your email to him to let him give his perspective on the Goodman review you requested. Here is his technical review of the packaged heat pump unit:

 
York Gas Furnace Reviews
Editor rating
 
1.0 User rating
 
1.0 (1)

York Gas Furnace Reviews

I get a lot of emails everyday for this site and some of my other sites and it is nearly impossible to respond to all the emails I get for this. I do read most of the emails and then respond by writing an article on the site that will benefit most of the people. I have received approximately 300 emails from people asking me if they should buy a York gas furnace over some other brand of gas furnace based on what they have read here on this site. I would not purchase a product from anyone if I knew they were lying to me about something especially a major purchase like air conditioning and heating equipment for my home. If I go and buy a car from a car dealer and I find the dealer has lied to me about something I walk away. The motivation for lying is sell you something and profit from it. I cannot prove nor am I saying the claim York made was a lie but simply read what I wrote and how York responded and make up your own mind. Going beyond that to me the most important part of air conditioning and heating systems is the installation of the equipment. I have observed first hand poor installations that led to big problems in air conditioning and heating systems so it is important that you select the correct and competent contractor to install the system. I can almost bet my house that many of the negative reviews you see here and at other sites was because the system was not installed correctly. They thought they were getting a good deal by hiring a friend of cousin Billybob to install the new system. Sure they saved some money on the install but in the end situations like this almost always end in misery for the consumer and the consumer who paid cousin Billybobs friend to install the system almost always blames the manufacturer. If you buy a York gas furnace make sure it is installed properly and you will get the most out of it whether it is an 80 AFUE or an 95 AFUE gas furnace. Proper installation will not only benefit efficiency of the equipment but also longevity or life of the equipment. Tell cousin Billybob thanks but no thanks and hire a good contractor to install the system. To help along the way you can buy the High Performance HVAC Equipment Buyers Guide. The Guide will help you select the proper contractor and ask the right questions about replacing your equipment.

To be updated soon based on a current response by York. Please see the comments below before making a judgement on York. I will always be fair with manufacturers and will update this review based on the response below. This site gets over 100,000 visitors a month (and rapidly growing) so there is some influence on people making purchases of HVAC equipment.  Look for an update soon about this issue. The "Caution Alert" has been removed for now. Thanks to York for finally responding.

York gas furnaces offer an efficiency range between 80% to what York claims is a whopping 98% AFUE - This claim beats Maytags claim of 97% AFUE! So are we raising the bar with efficiency or is the testing for efficiency have holes in it and subject to massaging the numbers so that a particular manufacturer can claim they have the most efficient furnace in the world? I am wondering when they tested this furnace in the lab did they use current DOE test which is actually a test designed only for single-stage gas furnaces and not two-stage or modulating gas furnaces? There are too many questions here and actually I find it hard to believe a gas furnace can get to 98% AFUE. I have many questions for York about this test that gave them the 98% AFUE rating on this gas furnace.

 
Heil QuietComfort VS 95 Gas Furnace Review
Editor rating
 
4.0 User rating
 
0.0 (0)

Heil QuietComfort VS 95 Gas Furnace Review

The Heil VS 95 Gas Furnace is Energy Star rated and is rated 95% AFUE for efficiency. This is the top of the line for Heil gas furnaces and since Heil is owned by ICP which is owned by Carriers parent company I would expect some good research and development by one of those companies before they release any products especially gas furnaces. The heat exchanger does come with a lifetime limited warranty and a 10 year parts limited warranty. Additionally, this gas furnace closely resembles the same furnace produced by other ICP companies but the name of the other furnace is AirQuest. Some features of the Heil VS 95 gas furnace include:

 
<< Start < Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next > End >>

Page 1 of 27

Random Reviews

User rating
 
1.0
Reviewed by Kimberly
"We have rented a hot water heater from Reliance since we moved into our New home built in 2005. I..."
Editor rating
 
3.8
Reviewed by Richard
"Do you own an American Standard Condensing Unit? If you own an American Standard Condensing Unit ..."
User rating
 
1.0
Reviewed by Randy Brown
" This unit worked well for airconditioning. However I had a 12 year old Lennox which had not gi..."

Popular Reviews

Top Editor Reviews

Air Conditioner and Heating Systems Reviews